Connect with us

Mental health

Discussing breast cancer density after screening linked to higher anxiety

Published

on

Telling women their breast density after screening was linked to higher anxiety and confusion than no notification, an Australian study suggests.

Breast density is the proportion of glandular and fibrous tissue compared with fat. Dense tissue is a risk factor for breast cancer and can make mammograms harder to interpret.

Women undergoing screening in Australia are already told their density, and the measure is being considered in the UK by the National Screening Committee.

Melanie Sturtevant, associate director of policy, evidence and influencing at Breast Cancer Now, said: “Knowing personal risk of breast cancer could allow people to make informed decisions about their own breast health.

“But studies like this one are really important to understand the impact of informing people about personal risk factors like breast density, including on a person’s mental health.

“The findings underline that learning they were higher risk left many women feeling more anxious and confused, and more likely to ask their GP for further information.”

Researchers at the University of Sydney studied 2,401 women screened between September 2023 and July 2024 who were classified as having dense breasts.

Participants were randomised to a control group (no density notice), a group notified with written information, or a group notified with a link to an explanatory video.

Eight weeks later, women were surveyed about their psychological response and whether they intended to speak to their GP or seek extra screening.

Those notified of their density were more likely to feel anxious and unsure what to do than the control group.

Intentions to talk to a GP were also higher among notified women: 22.8 per cent and 19.4 per cent in the written and video groups, compared with 12.9 per cent in the control group.

The NHS breast screening programme in England does not currently assess or record breast density on screening mammograms.

Sophie Brooks, health information manager at Cancer Research UK, said that having dense breasts could make it harder to detect cancer on a mammogram, but it was not something people could check for themselves or change.

She added: “This study suggests that telling women about their breast density has mixed results.

“Women who were told were more likely to seek advice from their GP, but they were also more likely to feel anxious and confused, highlighting the need for clear information and support.

“More research is needed to investigate whether informing women about their breast density could have a positive impact or not, and the UK National Screening Committee are currently looking into this.”

The study concluded that women notified of dense breasts “felt anxious and confused, did not feel more informed to make decisions about their breast health, and wanted to be guided by their general practitioners”.

Sturtevant said: “Currently in the UK, routine screening does not involve recording information about breast density, and a review into whether additional screening should be offered to women with dense breasts is ongoing.

“While we appreciate the need for a strong, evidence-driven process, we want to see the UK National Screening Committee conduct this with more urgency and transparency.”

Menopause

More research needed to understand link between brain fog and menopause, expert says

Published

on

Brain fog in menopause is common but still poorly understood, with researchers calling for more work to explain the link and how best to support women.

For a new perspective article published in The Lancet Obstetrics, Gynaecology, & Women’s Health, researchers based in the UK and Australia reviewed the evidence on menopause-related cognitive symptoms. They found that symptoms such as forgetfulness, reduced concentration and brain fog are common during the menopause transition, but are still poorly recognised and under-researched.

More than two-thirds of women report difficulties with memory or concentration over the menopause transition. Multiple factors may contribute to these cognitive symptoms, including hormonal changes, sleep disturbances and psychological and psychosocial stress. Yet, because cognitive symptoms are not widely discussed, they can cause considerable worry, with some fearing they are signs of dementia or undiagnosed neurodevelopmental conditions.

The review paper emphasises that overall cognitive performance for women experiencing menopause-related brain fog typically remains within expected ranges and, importantly, that cognitive symptoms are not linked to an increased risk of dementia.

Professor Aimee Spector of UCL Division of Psychology and Language Sciences, co-author on the paper, said: “Cognitive symptoms such as forgetfulness and ‘brain fog’ are incredibly common during menopause, yet they are often overlooked. Our findings highlight just how complex menopause-related cognitive symptoms are, and how much we still don’t know about what drives them. More targeted research is essential if we are to identify which biological, psychological or lifestyle factors contribute most, and what types of support or treatment are likely to be effective.”

The authors argue that clinicians can play a key role in understanding and validating women’s experiences by asking about the duration of cognitive symptoms, impacts on day-to-day functioning and any other medical or psychosocial factors that could be contributing to cognitive symptoms.

The review also discusses a range of approaches that may ease cognitive symptoms, such as improving sleep quality, engaging in regular aerobic exercise and eating a balanced diet. There is also little but promising research into the impact of psychological therapies targeting cognitive symptoms, with a recent meta-analysis of three cognitive behavioural therapy-based studies showing significant improvements in memory and concentration. The evidence is more mixed for the benefits of hormone therapy on cognitive symptoms during menopause.

The authors identify cognitive symptoms as a major area of unmet need in menopause research. They call for a unified definition of menopause-related cognitive changes and for prospective, longitudinal studies that can track women from pre- to post-menopause. Better understanding of the biological, psychological and social factors that contribute to cognitive symptoms will be crucial for developing effective treatments.

Lead researcher Dr Caroline Gurvich of Monash University said: “There’s a lot of pressure to use objective measures of cognitive decline, like a memory test, for example, in a clinical trial, but the key symptom of brain fog is a subjective experience. So having a definition that acknowledges the key cognitive symptom is critical.”

This is not without precedent – we already use subjective or self-report measures for depression, anxiety and other mental health conditions with great success.

Dr Gurvich said the proposed definition would also validate women’s individual experiences while empowering them through the reassurance that any objective decline in their cognitive ability is subtle.

She added: “This is a decrease in cognitive or learning efficiency, not functionality or capacity. For many women, the perception they are losing capacity is what drives them to stop work or lose the confidence to live fulfilling lives during and after menopause. I hear all the time from women who have gone through menopause that validation would have made a significant difference to their resilience and the approach they took to living with menopause.”

Co-author Professor Martha Hickey of the University of Melbourne and Royal Women’s Hospital said: “Our analysis of the best available research shows that many women experience some degree of cognitive symptoms, such as brain fog, during the menopause transition.”

“But there’s a lack of long-term data, which means that there’s a gap in our knowledge about how the brain fog symptom develops and changes from peri-menopause to after menopause ends. It’s a real gap in our understanding.”

Professor Spector added: “We increasingly see women, typically at the peak of their careers, losing confidence in the workplace, often translating to leaving work or reducing work hours. Having simple strategies to support and retain them at work is also a broader economic issue.”

Continue Reading

Mental health

Inflammation linked to depression in women with diabetes, study finds

Published

on

Inflammation may help flag depression in women with type 2 diabetes, new research reveals, but the link appears to vary by symptoms and by how depression is measured.

The findings suggest both the promise and the challenge of identifying biomarkers, measurable indicators in blood or other tests, for depression.

Women with type 2 diabetes are at higher risk of depression, which can accelerate diabetes complications, impair functioning and increase the risk of death. Research suggests inflammation may be a key link between the two conditions, as certain inflammatory biomarkers are frequently found in both.

Scientists have yet to identify an objective diagnostic biomarker for depression, such as something measured through blood work, a genetic test or a brain scan.

To diagnose and measure depression, mental health providers usually use questionnaires. Some add up the number of symptoms as a checklist, while others measure the severity of different symptoms.

Depression can also look very different from one person to the next, with symptoms spanning physical effects such as sleeping too much or too little, mood-related issues such as persistent sadness, and cognitive difficulties such as trouble concentrating.

Nicole Beaulieu Perez, assistant professor at NYU Rory Meyers College of Nursing and study author, said: “Depression is the most measured construct in all of science, but part of our problem is that we’re not defining depression the same, there may be different types, but we’re lumping them all together.

“The variability in depression symptoms complicates how we diagnose and treat it, particularly in the absence of validated biological markers.”

To better understand the connection between inflammation and different symptoms and measures of depression, researchers at NYU Rory Meyers College of Nursing studied 38 women with type 2 diabetes, many of whom were also living with HIV.

They analysed blood samples for 10 different inflammatory biomarkers, including CRP, IL-6, IL-4 and IL-8.

They also assessed participants for depression using PROMIS, an NIH-developed series of short questionnaires that includes measures of depression, anxiety, sleep and fatigue, as well as the CES-D, an older measure that adds up depression symptoms.

The researchers found that certain inflammatory biomarkers were linked to depression, but the associations varied depending on the measures and symptoms used.

Higher levels of depression and anxiety measured using PROMIS were associated with lower levels of IL-4.

They also found contradictory associations for CRP and IL-6. Both were positively correlated with depression when it was measured using CES-D and negatively correlated when it was measured using PROMIS.

Sleep disturbances measured using PROMIS were associated with IL-8.

Perez said: “It was interesting to see that, in some cases, the direction of these associations flipped entirely based on which measure of depression we were using.”

The findings, while preliminary because of the small number of people studied, suggest that the link between inflammatory biomarkers and depression may not be consistent across all measures or symptoms.

More research is needed to tease out the role of inflammation and whether subtypes of depression can be identified based on symptoms and objective biological markers.

Perez said: “We think there’s something going on with inflammation and depression, but if we look closely, we may find that’s true for some forms of depression but not others.”

She said she hoped that in future, pairing depression measures with biomarkers such as blood tests could provide more objectivity in diagnosing depression, which could help further destigmatise mental illness, as well as help clinicians catch it earlier and guide treatment.

Perez said: “Precision mental health has great potential.

“If we can identify a specific type of depression, for instance, one that appears to be driven by inflammation, this may inform which medications to try to target an underlying biological pathology, hopefully reducing the trial and error often needed to find an effective treatment for depression.

“By identifying specific inflammatory biomarkers linked to different dimensions of mental health, our findings suggest a path toward precision mental health that moves beyond one-size-fits-all approaches.”

Continue Reading

Pregnancy

Miscarriage cradle to be rolled out across Scotland

Published

on

A ‘miscarriage cradle’ is being introduced at three Scottish hospitals to help women experiencing miscarriage at home and in hospital.

The device was created by engineer Laura Corcoran after she lost her third baby.

Forced to devise her own way of collecting her baby’s remains, she came up with a solution to deal with the physical side so women could focus on their emotional loss.

Corcoran said: “My husband and I are both engineers, we went into problem-solving mode and we ended up using a kitchen sieve to collect baby over the toilet and then we used a Chinese takeout container to store baby in the fridge over the weekend, the hospital said I wasn’t allowed to bring them in out of hours and I miscarried on a Friday evening.”

Corcoran described the ordeal as ‘a really awful time’ and said she felt very vulnerable.

“It was completely undignified and it felt like I didn’t matter, my baby didn’t matter, there was nothing fit for purpose,” she added.

NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde is the first UK health board to roll out its use.

The Royal Alexandra Hospital in Paisley, the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital and Princess Royal Maternity in Glasgow will offer the device to support women through miscarriage at home and in hospital.

It is believed to be the first time a group of hospitals in the UK has committed to embedding this type of support across multiple sites.

Laura’s invention came out of one of the darkest moments of her life, as she began to miscarry for the third time.

She was bleeding but was told there was no space for her in hospital and that she would have to manage the process at home.

Laura told BBC Scotland News: “Within the NHS, you have to miscarry three times before you are eligible for testing to try to find some answers.”

She said she asked the early pregnancy unit how to collect the baby and they said ‘just to manage’.

During her recovery, Laura became angry that she had not been given the tools she needed to navigate the process.

But then she realised it was not just her, there was nothing fit for purpose for any woman dealing with baby loss.

“Using my background as an engineer, I started cutting up cardboard, taping bits together, sketching ideas.

“When I had something, I went to the 3D printers and printed the first prototype,” Corcoran said.

After patient and clinical feedback, she arrived at the device now in use.

The device is semi-circular and sits under the toilet seat. In the centre is a removable sieve. It filters out what is not needed and keeps the baby.

It then goes into a watertight storage container which can be taken to hospital for testing, or for a burial or cremation.

Corcoran said: “It allows women not to have to think of the practical aspects, to think about the emotional aspects, the grief. It gives them some space and time.

“The possibility that you might not be able to collect the baby and get access to testing adds weight to the problem.

“To be able to collect the baby respectfully and without cross-contamination means women can get access to testing, find potential causes and then prevent them going through it again in their next pregnancy.”

Corcoran said an independent economic report for NHS England showed that 50 per cent uptake would save the NHS in Scotland £11.2m, free up 12,000 gynaecology surgery slots and save 10,000 emergency department visits.

Continue Reading

Trending

Copyright © 2025 Aspect Health Media Ltd. All Rights Reserved.