Fertility & pregnancy Diagnosis Fertility in Focus Care & services Opinion Insight

Monash IVF admits second embryo mix-up in three months at Australian clinic

By Published On: June 11, 2025
Monash IVF admits second embryo mix-up in three months at Australian clinic

A Victorian woman undergoing IVF treatment received her own embryo instead of her partner’s, Monash IVF has confirmed—marking the second reported mix-up at the fertility company in recent months.

The error, which occurred in June, was revealed in a statement to the ASX on Tuesday.

Monash IVF said the patient’s embryo was transferred “contrary to the treatment plan”, which had specified the embryo of her partner.

It follows a separate incident announced in April, when a woman at a Queensland clinic gave birth to a child conceived with another couple’s embryo.

Monash IVF said it had extended “sincere apologies” to the latest affected couple and was continuing to support them.

The Victorian health regulator has launched an investigation. The state’s health minister, Mary-Anne Thomas, said the company would be required to cooperate fully.

Thomas said in a statement: “Families should have confidence that the treatment they are receiving is done to the highest standard.”

She later told reporters Monash IVF’s “clinical governance standards are not where they should be”.

She said: “This will be quite devastating for the couple at the heart of this.

“The IVF journey can be long, torturous and very expensive. To not be respected, to not have your treatment plan followed—I can’t even imagine how that couple are feeling right now.”

The first incident was attributed to human error.

Monash IVF appointed senior counsel Fiona McLeod to lead an independent investigation, which has now been extended to cover the second case.

The latest incident has renewed concerns about safety protocols in fertility clinics.

Dr Hilary Bowman-Smart is a bioethicist at the University of South Australia.

 Bowman-Smart said: “In reproductive care, trust is everything.

“This mix-up – the second reported incident at Monash IVF – risks shaking confidence not just in one provider, but across the entire fertility sector.”

Dr Evie Kendal, senior lecturer in health promotion at Swinburne University of Technology, said the cases showed how human involvement in reproduction carried risks.

She said: “Previous safeguards are clearly not up to the challenge of protecting clients against such incidents, and urgent ethical and policy guidance is needed to prevent such mistakes from occurring again.”

Monash IVF said it was introducing additional verification processes and patient confirmation steps “over and above normal practice and electronic witness systems” to restore confidence in its procedures.

It noted that while electronic witness systems were being rolled out, there were still circumstances where manual checks were required.

Associate professor Alex Polyakov from the University of Melbourne and medical director at Genea Fertility described the events as “profoundly troubling”, but added they remained “extraordinarily uncommon”.

Monash IVF has notified assisted reproductive technology regulators and its insurers about the incident.

Domestic violence survivors face long-term brain injury and mental health risks, study suggests
Cervical screening interval for women under 50 in England to change from three to five years