UK LGBTQ+ population faces barriers to fertility treatment, research finds

LGBTQ+ people across the UK face discrimination, funding inequalities and gaps in fertility care, research has found.

Eligibility for NHS-funded treatment varies across the country, while many services are still structured around heterosexual couples.

People with diverse sexual orientations and gender identities can be left navigating complex systems, paying more for treatment and explaining their needs to healthcare professionals.

Co-author Dr Chloe He, of the UCL Institute of Epidemiology and Health Care, said: “Legal access is not the same as equitable access. LGBTQ+ patients are forced to navigate a Kafkaesque fertility care system alone – researching, self-advocating, and often educating the doctors and nurses treating them.

“In our study, we saw clinicians with no formal LGBTQ+ training, gay men pressured into being relentlessly cheerful to prove parent-worthiness to surrogacy services, and patients travelling hundreds of miles for care after experiencing transphobia at local clinics.”

The University of Stirling-led research involved 54 participants and 36 in-depth interviews with people who had used fertility services and professionals working in or alongside fertility care across the UK.

Researchers from Stirling, SKEMA Business School and University College London examined the extra work undertaken by LGBTIQA+ people seeking to have children.

They called this “reproductive labour”, which includes researching treatment, advocating for themselves, covering additional costs and educating clinicians.

The researchers said this work was used to manage “reproductive bioprecarity”, a term describing the uncertainty and vulnerability people can face while seeking reproductive healthcare.

The study, funded by a Santander Universities Research Grant, primarily reflected the experiences of cisgender lesbian participants.

One participant, Amanda, said she and her partner, Amy, spent a long time trying to find a GP willing to discuss fertility with them.

The couple eventually underwent fertility tests through the NHS, but their private clinic rejected the results because they had not been referred by a GP.

They had to repeat the tests and pay for them privately.

The researchers said lesbian couples are often required to self-fund multiple rounds of intrauterine insemination before becoming eligible for NHS support.

Intrauterine insemination, or IUI, involves placing sperm directly into the womb.

Gay men usually have to pursue surrogacy, which is not funded or supported by the NHS, while transgender people can face long waits to save eggs and sperm to allow them to have children.

Lead author Dr Carolyn Wilson-Nash, senior lecturer at the University of Stirling Business School, began investigating the issue after she and her wife made multiple attempts to conceive and faced challenges throughout the process.

The couple funded almost the entire process themselves and consulted a GP who had no experience of supporting same-sex couples seeking fertility care.

The researchers called for clearer treatment pathways, more inclusive services and better training for healthcare staff.

Dr Wilson-Nash, who is now the mother of a three-year-old boy, said: “The way the current system for fertility services is set up in the UK can lead to unequal pathways for the LGBTIQA+ population.

“For example, heterosexual couples can access NHS-funded in vitro fertilisation (IVF), whereas lesbian couples are often required to self-fund multiple rounds of intrauterine insemination (IUI) before becoming eligible for NHS support.

“Gay men usually have to pursue surrogacy, which is not funded by or supported by the NHS.

“And transgender individuals often face long waiting times to save eggs and sperm to allow them to have children. So legal access does not necessarily translate into equitable or inclusive care.

“Building a family should be neither exclusive nor this difficult. Fertility services should be available to all, regardless of their sexual orientation or gender identity.”

Laura-Rose Thorogood, founder of LGBT Mummies and part of the UK’s Fertility Justice Campaign, said: “Right now, intended LGBTQIA+ parents are being discriminated against because of who they are, and who they love.

“This is ultimately forcing them down alternative pathways which in turn put them at long-term risk physically, psychologically and socially.

“By providing access to treatment, our community can thrive and create the families they dream of by their chosen route.”